Normalized Ratings Comparison Across Major Reviewers
How to read this table:
Raw is each rater's original score. Norm is a z-score, so +1 means one standard deviation above that rater's average.
Averages and controversy ignore missing values (blanks are not treated as zeros).
Use sort/search and the rarity toggles to narrow the list. Hover a name for the image and click it for Scryfall.
Click the source headers to jump to the original reviews.
With thanks to Spike_der_Spiegel on reddit for giving me the idea and compiling the information for LLU, LR and CGB, and DS commons and uncommons.